Audi A5 Forum & Audi S5 Forum banner
41 - 60 of 75 Posts
Discussion starter · #41 ·
Yeah as CadGuy showed in the pics, that is how you tell the difference. If it has the bulbus bit on the back of the caliper, then it's the smaller caliper. The larger ones are more flat on the back.

They are quite rare! As Cadguy found and ended up biting the bullet and getting brand new ones! I have seen brand new ones from AutoDoc at about ÂŁ250 each, so if you can as Cadguy did and get a deal then the new ones are an option.
 
Cheers Dave

For a laugh I'll give both Porsche and Audi a call and get a quote for new ones.

As said above, not is a rush as I've just put new pads in but want to do this by next MOT in August next year.

With new calipers, disks and pads prob going to be around ÂŁ1k, so a bit of a investment.
 
Discussion starter · #43 ·
Found a caliper on AutoDoc! https://www.autodoc.co.uk/abs/13866576

yeah let us know what price Audi says (if they can actually give you price as these calipers seem to have a lot of different part numbers!

I paid ÂŁ400 for USR discs and Yellowstuff pads all round! My calipers were a bit rough so only paid ÂŁ150 for the pair!
 
So there is a surcharge od ÂŁ22 on those, so ÂŁ220 each and I assume with Autodoc I would be liable for import duty, so adds another 20%. Probably total around ÂŁ260 all in each. Which to be fair it's not that bad as I don't need to refurb them, but will want to paint them gloss black.

I'll see what Audi and Porsche come back with....
 
Discussion starter · #48 ·
So there is a surcharge od ÂŁ22 on those, so ÂŁ220 each and I assume with Autodoc I would be liable for import duty, so adds another 20%. Probably total around ÂŁ260 all in each. Which to be fair it's not that bad as I don't need to refurb them, but will want to paint them gloss black.

I'll see what Audi and Porsche come back with....
Yeah, when I was originally looking, I saw them at about ÂŁ120, but then had a ÂŁ150 surcharge! :D

I think for a brand new pair, you should be able to get them for around ÂŁ500ish
 
Porsche Macan Front Caliper Kit with Brake Lines - s4 b8

Still at a good price for new calipers and HEL braided lines.

These are Brembo stamped originals, and not ABS copies

I spent forever waiting for a used pair to pop up on the bay. So bit the bullet with these, as I would have had to get someone to refurbish a used set anyway.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TonyP
Discussion starter · #50 ·
Yeah was going to mention that, the AutoDoc ones are aftermarket. But the Brembo branding is on the back of the caliper and you don't see it. :)

Had mine on 18months now and they've been great, with still loads of life on the pads and discs, but I don't do a lot of miles!
 
Porsche Macan Front Caliper Kit with Brake Lines - s4 b8

Still at a good price for new calipers and HEL braided lines.

These are Brembo stamped originals, and not ABS copies

I spent forever waiting for a used pair to pop up on the bay. So bit the bullet with these, as I would have had to get someone to refurbish a used set anyway.
Just revisiting this topic. Cadguy, did you repaint these, and did you add S5 stickers on them? Is the Porsche writing smooth or does it sit proud of the surface?
 
  • Like
Reactions: TonyP
Discussion starter · #53 ·
I think the Porsche decals will be very thin and the paint shop may have took them off? :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: TonyP
@Dave Kwatro would you recommend the yellowstuff pads? It's soon time for new pads and I need to decide on OE vs something else. Although they seem to be quiet now these brakes used to squeal a lot and so I am reluctant to use the OE pads again. Based on EBC info it would seem that yellowstuff are the quietest. What's your opinion?
 
Discussion starter · #55 · (Edited)
I had redstuff on my 3.0tdi and they were great with hardly any dust and the dust that came off them were more grey/beige so the wheel looked clean!

EBC recommend Redstuff for the S5, so they will be fine for yours as a direct replacement. @Smokey Joe has red stuff on his too! But with tuned S5s, Ebc recommends moving up to Yellowstuff. Joe actually won his EBC redstuff pads on this forum via a EBC representative! :)

I find them to have good bite when cold and when hot. Not had any signs of fade or going a bit 'wooden'. They can hum a bit at motorway plus speeds and pressing them firmly, but this might be due to my slotted discs. I don't always notice this due to not doing high speed braking often.

I have noticed at a certain temp, when getting warm, they can have a bit of squeak, nothing like Carbon Lorraines or track focused carbon pads. Only under light braking once warm, give them a few more presses and the temp increases, the squeak goes. I don't always notice it, probably as it only does it at a certain temperature. Like you, I do have a bit of OCD with my car and don't like unusual noises, but the squeak isn't enough to trigger my OCD anyway.

If you have slotted rotors and do some fast or heavy stops, you can get some dust build up, which I think may be similar to OE pads, but with plain discs, the dust will be less.

I rate the Redstuff for braking and keeping the alloys clean and the Yellowstuff for the extra performance, especially on the tuned S5 as a little squirt in 3rd gear can see triple figures come up quite quickly! :)

Also EBC discounts can be had quite easily 20-25%, so let me know if you struggle to obtain the discount codes.

I got EBC USR disks and Yellow stuff pads all round for ÂŁ400 delivered next day! But the front pads are about ÂŁ30 cheaper than OEM calipers with the 4 pot brembos on mine. :)

But yes, fully recommend the Yellowstuff pads! (y)
 
I did a lot of reading around when I looked into replacement pads for the OEM calipers on my S5. I was keen on low dust but decent performance for normal road use. I bought some to try but due to low mileage I haven't needed to fit them yet. I ended up buying a set of Hawk Performance ceramic pads for the rears ( click here ) and Akebono Euro Ultra-Premium ceramic pads for the fronts (click here ). I paid ÂŁ90 for the Hawks imported from US via Ebay and ÂŁ50 for the Akebonos open box, ex-stock from Awesome GTI. I'm on 22k miles on the original pads so I imagine not too long until I have to change them.
 
Discussion starter · #57 ·
I've read good reviews on Akebono and Hawk pads - but was a bit difficult sourcing them and as you have done, may be only from the US.
 
Thanks Dave. I think I'll go for the yellow.
 
Discussion starter · #60 ·
Yes! :) I just didn't get the RS brakes due to funds!

They should fit, my Dad's A6 looks like the std calipers from the A5. They look in good condition with little wear! The problem with buying 2nd hand is the disc and pad condition as they are expensive to replace. The pads look like 1 big pad, the RS5 had 2 pads each side of the disc so 8 pads in total upfront.

Just wondering why they are photographed on the car, normally they are off the car. If you buy them, hope they are the ones in the picture! Those wavey discs are about ÂŁ1k each!
 
  • Like
Reactions: SimonRoma
41 - 60 of 75 Posts