Oh dear !!! Black wheels to me just look like you can't be arsed to clean them. That car looks like its got spacers on, the rear wheels seem to fill out to the edge of the arch better than stock. Certainly lower.
I don't like either. If he had left a original color trim arround or paint the trim red maybe it looks hot. I've seen it on a M3 and it looks awsome. Also the black color used is a bit pale, a shinny black looks better.