[sandjstickney]

Don't overlook the advantages of AWD that the Audi offers. (although snow tires are a must)

That fact alone would leave the S5 as my only choice. Considering where you live I assume it's a consideration for you as well.

 

[sandjstickney]

If exclusivity and looks factor in, I gotta give the nod to the S5. Also, as an 09 S5 Coupe driver myself (and 55k miles in) I can tell you that it STILL makes me feel special when I'm behind the wheel. Does the Benz give you that?

 

[sandjstickney]

The Benz will be softer.
The Audi will be harder.

The Benz leans "feminine" (pipe down...we all know it's true).
The Audi is masculine without saying meathead.

The Benz tries to be your friend a bit too much.
The Audi...really doesn't care what you think.

The Benz might make for a good date occasionally.
The Audi you're proud to put a ring on.

BTW, I too am an Executive, 45, by the name of Steve. .

The engineer in you will be happy with either car; listen now to that disquieting voice of your emotion. Most of us on this board are halfway dead and have made sensible choices our whole lives. Go seemingly crazy-nuts for a change.

 

[sandjstickney]

Come to KC, we'll share a beer and pat each other on the back.

 

[sandjstickney]

Keep us posted Steve.