There's nothing in Armor All that should permanently discolor plastic. Try mixing a spray bottle with water and Dawn dish washing liquid.Spray and clean the area with a rag or soft bristle brush. Rinse with plain water. Good luck.
2012 Premium Plus A5 2.0T, Teak/BeigeLinen/Walnut Inserts, MMI Nav Plus, B&O Audio, Parking Sensors, Advance Key/ Hardwired V1, Hardwired BlueTooth Audio, Dash mounted Hardwired iPod Touch, Infinity BassLink Powered Subwoofer, Drivers Seat Lumbar delete